Lists Are Great; Lists Can Be Constraining: It’s all about how we use them.

August signals the end of summer.  People take the last chance for vacation, and the pace of life seems to take a couple of notches down…for some.  So, I will continue my summer-lite writing for light reading.

—————–

I live with lists.  I don’t always follow them, but they provide both a compass and a reminder.  Somehow, when it comes to management issues, though, I rail against lists.  The “10 best ideas for…,” or “7 ways to…,” or, “5 lessons or secrets…”  My least favorite is “6 ways to talk like a leader.”  Not so much that there are only “6 ways,” but trumpeting talking “like” a leader smacks of a PR stunt.  Why not actually help people be leaders?

My treasured blog, www.brainpickings.org, by Maria Popova, uses lists a lot.  The author calls them “listicles.”  Funny.  I don’t find the listicles on this site offending, and I think it has a lot to do with the issue of framing.  In the context of creativity, which is a huge focus of “brainpickings”, the lists open doors and windows.  Hopefully, when we read these lists, they give us clues and perhaps keys to further explore within ourselves.

Creative Mornings: Maria Popova on Content Cur...

Creative Mornings: Maria Popova on Content Curation (Photo credit: deanmeyersnet)

In the context of business world, however, I fear lists tend to limit people.  In a stressful and busy work environment, when we see a list, it’s likely that’s all we follow.  It’s a checklist, a list to discharge obligations, not to open more possibilities.  Amazon’s Jeff Bezos famously rejects PowerPoint presentations because people get lazy when they see these bullet points; they miss the nuances.  Instead, whenever an Amazon employee wants to push an idea, Bezos’ policy is “write a narrative.”  This is to help people really focus on what they want to advocate, and how to advance the idea.

Like “categories,” lists have similar effects of constraining people in the business world:  We box in others.  We sometimes box in ourselves too, but usually we want to use the labels on others.   The more unfamiliar we are with the subject, situation, or people, the more we “need” categories and lists.  We think it’s a shortcut to help us to get things moving or done.  And sometimes they are helpful.  But ultimately, categories or lists are only guidelines; they inform.  For instance, Meyers-Briggs’ personality types, introvert-extrovert, intuition-sensing, thinking-feeling, and perception-judging, are interesting to explore and to inform us about ourselves and our colleagues.  Even if this inventory test were perfect – which it is certainly not – it cannot capture all of who we are in a neat 4×2 space.

Finally, management is about understanding and working with relationships.  Dynamics of relationships, be they about duos, or small or large groups, are fluid.  Lists and categories largely capture only snapshots.  I contend that a manager who follows all the lists in the management literature is the worst manager.  A good manager is attuned to nuances, is flexible, and knows when a list is a friend and when it’s binding.  Am I making a list?!

Do you have a favorite list that has inspired you?

Till next time,

Staying Sane and Charging Ahead.

Direct Contact:  taso100@gmail.com

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s